Cari Blog Ini

Diberdayakan oleh Blogger.
Selasa, 11 Oktober 2016

The proposed press publishers' right: is it really worth all this noise?

The proposed press publishers' right: is it really worth all this noise? - welcome to the blog Software Gadget the end of this much calm product information launcing, yes every day there are always products that are removed from various brands, both physical hardware products and software that need new knowledge to use it, well now we will discuss first about The proposed press publishers' right: is it really worth all this noise? as you search we have collected a lot of data to make this information as complete as possible for you, please read:

Articles : The proposed press publishers' right: is it really worth all this noise?
full Link : The proposed press publishers' right: is it really worth all this noise?
Article Article 11 DSM Directive, Article Digital Single Market Strategy, Article EU copyright, Article press publishers' right,

You can also see our article on:


The proposed press publishers' right: is it really worth all this noise?

Again on the proposal
(for a directive on copyright
in the Digital Single Market)
As reported and covered in a number of previous posts [here, here, here], in the context of its Digital Single Market Strategy (DSMS) on 14 September last the EU Commission unveiled a new copyright package, consisting of a number of proposals aimed at improving the existing EU copyright framework.

Among the contents of the package, there is the already famous proposal for a directive on copyright in the Digital Single Market (DSM Directive) [here]

Among other things, the DSM Directive intends to introduce into the EU copyright framework a new related right in press publications.

Article 11 of the directive states:

"1. Member States shall provide publishers of press publications [what is to be intended by 'press publications' is clarified at Recital 33 of the directive] with the rights provided for in Article 2 and Article 3(2) of Directive 2001/29/EC for the digital use of their press publications. 
2. The rights referred to in paragraph 1 shall leave intact and shall in no way affect any rights provided for in Union law to authors and other rightholders, in respect of the works and other subject-matter incorporated in a press publication. Such rights may not be invoked against those authors and other rightholders and, in particular, may not deprive them of their right to exploit their works and other subject-matter independently from the press publication in which they are incorporated. 
3. Articles 5 to 8 of Directive 2001/29/EC [the InfoSoc Directive] and Directive 2012/28/EU [the Orphan Works Directive] shall apply mutatis mutandis in respect of the rights referred to in paragraph 1. 
4. The rights referred to in paragraph 1 shall expire 20 years after the publication of the press publication. This term shall be calculated from the first day of January of the year following the date of publication."

However, the drafting of this provision and related recitals (31 to 36) raises a number of technical questions, as well as a practical, fundamental, one.

When less may be actually more
The technical questions

A first question may be why Article 11 refers to Article 3(2) of the InfoSoc Directive [making available right] instead of Article 3(1) of the same directive [right of communication to the public], also considering that the last sentence in Recital 33 refers to the right of communication to the public. 

The question is not just pedanticacademic, because the rights of communication to the public and making available to the public are not the same thing. The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) has made this clear, more recently in its C More judgment [here].

A second point is that it is not entirely clear why Recital 33 contains a reference to hyperlinks, by saying that those which do not amount to acts of communication to the public are outside the scope of the new right. 

First, the new related right is not about the right of communication to the public, but rather reproduction and making available to the public. 

Secondly, if the new related right does not go beyond copyright [as Article 11(2) stresses], surely saying that "protection does not extend to acts of hyperlinking which do not constitute communication to the public" is not really necessary. 

Finally, hyperlinks are not everything the right is about: Article 11 refers to the "digital use" of press publications. A "digital use" may range from the scanning of press publications to the display of relevant excerpts and everything in between.

Charlie is scared ...
but is there anything to really fear?
A practical question

Last week I had the chance to speak to a number of people, both stakeholders and legal practitioners, over meals and at events. While coming from different positions in relation to the current EU copyright debate, they all seemed to have the same question:

Will the press publishers' right have any practical relevance?

Despite some earlier academic concerns, the answer may be 'NO' in the majority of cases. The reason for this is twofold.

First, the new press publishers' right is certainly not broader than copyright (and is certainly shorter). Article 11 is clear in saying that the rights of reproduction and making available, along with related exceptions and limitations, are to be intended in the same sense as the same rights and exceptions under the copyright framework. So, to one who already owns the copyright to a press publication, will ownership of also the press publishers’ right mean anything (useful)?

Secondly - as a matter of practice and possibly with the exclusion of certain free-lance journalists who manage to retain ownership of copyright in their pieces - press publishers already own the copyright to the press publications authored by their journalists-employees. And copyright already provides a fairly powerful tool. Just to provide an example, yesterday I re-read the CJEU decision in Infopaq in preparation for the second IP class with my Southampton Law School undergraduate students.

Readers will promptly remember that that case - a reference for a preliminary ruling from Denmark - concerned indeed press publications scanned without the prior consent or relevant rightholders, ie press publishers. 

The CJEU ended up saying that merely "storing an extract of a protected work comprising 11 words and printing out that extract, is such as to come within the concept of reproduction in part within the meaning of Article 2 of Directive 2001/29/EC ..., if the elements thus reproduced are the expression of the intellectual creation of their author".

Would have things been any better if - besides copyright - press publishers could have also invoked the ad hoc press publishers' right in an Infopaq-like scenario?

Conclusion

All in all, it is unclear whether and to what extent the press publishers' right will change things in relation to digital uses of press publications.

Also the reference to the CJEU decision in Reprobel [here] in Recital 36 seems a bit out of context [and possibly only makes sense if, instead of Article 11, it is read as referring to Article 12], since that decision nothing had to do with digital uses of press publications. Reprobel was completely a non-digital case concerning private copying levies in printers.

In the majority of cases the addition of the press publishers’ right extra-layer of protection is unlikely to make a difference. But am I missing something here? As always, readers' feedback is very welcome!



so much information The proposed press publishers' right: is it really worth all this noise?

hopefully the information The proposed press publishers' right: is it really worth all this noise? that we provide can be useful for you in the set of technology products that fit your daily needs,

have just read the article titled The proposed press publishers' right: is it really worth all this noise? if you feel useful information and you want to bookmark or share please use the link https://ramblingsofker.blogspot.com/2016/10/the-proposed-press-publishers-right-is.html and do not forget to go back to this blog if you want to know information about the latest gadgets.

Tag : , , , ,
Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on Google+

Related : The proposed press publishers' right: is it really worth all this noise?

28 komentar:

  1. Tips for buying a copy here.replica balenciaga uk People spend a lot of time searching on the Internet, where there are many replicas of famous designer brands on sale,replica balenciaga hoodies and we can be sure that they are of high quality and quality.

    BalasHapus
  2. You place your hand gingerly on his solid cock. He’s circumcised, which pleases you. Decently endowed, too. Not a mammoth dick, by any means, but you can certainly have fun with this. You take him into your mouth, and before long, she comes down to join you. You feel her cheek Blonde fucked in car bush against yours as you’re both licking his shaft. You let her take over sucking him. As you move to lick his balls, you place your hand on his bare chest and feel him fall back into his pillow throne.

    You both get up on to your knees, making out in front of him again. You fiddle behind her back with one hand to release the clasp of her bra, and wonder why so many guys seem to have such a hard time accomplishing this minor feat. It falls to the floor with a soft thump, Wild orgy sex with lusty teens and you place a hand on each of her plump breasts. You realise this is the first time you’ve ever really explored a woman’s body that isn’t your own.

    With a grin, he gets up onto his knees, and kisses each of you one at a time. He then leans down onto his chest, turns to one side, and starts licking his girlfriend’s pussy. You can hear the sound of his hungry tongue lapping at her clit, and you rub his head encouragingly Tattooed Milf gets gangbanged as you press your lips to her once more. You feel his hair graze your own clit, and you press your pelvic bone gently into the side of his head.

    Rising to her hands, she pushes her breasts towards his face. He takes her nipple in his mouth, and swirls his tongue around the areola, releasing it with an aggressive smack. You put his cock, lubricated with your saliva, back into her vagina for her to pick up where she left off. Hot amateur likes to get fucked She grinds slowly back and forth over him, and he aggressively exhales a sigh of approval.

    Somewhere in the darkness, she fumbles around in the nightstand and finds a condom. She tears the wrapper Latina girlfriend homemade sex tape away and rejoins you and her boyfriend on the bed. You press your lips against his shaft gently on the outward stroke, and pull away to make way for her. She places the condom at the tip of his penis, unrolls it onto his cock, and implies that you get up on him.

    BalasHapus
  3. Welcome to our website established to watch the best Indian Porn Videos. Every day we add the best quality Desi Porn videos. In addition, we constantly share the latest indian porn videos. Watch thousands of free indian sex videos for free and if you want to download or keep them on your computer you can do it. hd porno Desi Sex, Indian

    Welcome to our website established to watch the best Indian Porn Videos. Every day we add the best quality Desi Porn videos. In addition, we constantly share the latest indian porn videos. Watch thousands of free indian sex videos for free and if you want to download or keep them on your computer you can do it.
    Desi Sex, Indian hot porn, Hd Porn, Quality Xxx.

    BalasHapus
  4. porn video
    Holly Hotwife is going about her horny single life: massaging her wet pussy with a vibrator until she is disturbed by a visitor: her ex-husband, Keiran Lee! Oh no! What does he want again? Turns out he got kicked out of his place and needs to crash on her couch. Holly has decided to keep things civil, but that all quickly goes out the window when she sees Keiran's throbbing boner under his boxers. One last dicking isn't gonna hurt, right? ... Okay maybe it will - but it hurts so good she doesn't care!


    sexy porn video
    is soaking wet in her ZZ debut! The busty blonde may be new to Brazzersland, but she's clearly no stranger to cock. Watch her get covered in oil from head to toe, or rather tits to ass (oh and what an ass it is!) before she takes Erik Everhard's big, slippery dick like a champ until she squirts all over the place. Oil and squirt are not the only things that get our babe wet, because she also happens to love a good, creamy facial.

    BalasHapus
  5. hot porn
    hard big dick ? Just select appropriate categories and enjoy. Narrow further and choose videos this amateurs or famous porn stars, nasty MILFs or shy teens in
    school uniforms doing the dirtiest stuff in high definition. Our collection will cover all tastes and perversionsindia sex

    BalasHapus
  6. desi porn
    beautiful girls. We have free porn from all over the world, you can find here anything from casual Caucasian, horny Ebony, dirtyhd porn video We have all the pussies you need. All you have to do is to sit back and enjoy indian sex

    BalasHapus
  7. brazzers porn
    Holly Hotwife is going about her horny single life: massaging her wet pussy with a vibrator until she is disturbed by a visitor: her ex-husband, Keiran Lee! Oh no! What does he want again?
    hd porn

    hot video
    Holly Hotwife is going about her horny single life: massaging her wet pussy with a vibrator until she is disturbed by a visitor: her ex-husband, Keiran Lee! Oh no! What does he want again?
    bbw porn

    BalasHapus
  8. Morena gostosa levando rola por trás em mais um excelente video porno HD. Uma transa alucinante com uma moreninha espetacular. Ela é realmente linda e gostosa na boafoda teen. Veja como a garota pelada exibe seus peitinhos maravilhosos e sua buceta perfeita. A putinha paga um delicioso boquete no pau grande do macho. Novinha chupando é um tesão! Veja que na hora de adr a buceta linda, a safada fica de quatro na cama. O cara mete com força na xoxota gostosa dela. A vadia começa a sentar no cacete do cara, cavalgando delicioso e gemendo muito. Muito excitante! Filmes de Sexo HD

    BalasHapus
  9. Meet real people performing solo and group shows in our adult video chat service. There are thousands of live porn cams to connect with at all times in an instant.

    BalasHapus
  10. Daily Free Porn Sexy woman beauty woman chubby woman beauty woman hd beauty woman sex tgline xxx woman beauty asian beautyfree asian beauty porn videos beauty asian tube hot asian orgasm.

    BalasHapus
  11. hd Anal porn
    Holly Hotwife is going about her horny single life: massaging her wet pussy with a vibrator until she is disturbed by a visitor: her ex-husband, Keiran Lee! Oh no! What does he want again?
    Amateur porn


    bbw hd porn
    quality videos on our website for free anywhere at any time. 4k porn video
    MILF porn
    If you are looking for.

    BalasHapus
  12. Lesbian Porn
    Holly Hotwife is going about her horny MILF pornsingle life: massaging her wet pussy with a vibrator until she is disturbed by a visitor: her ex-husband, Keiran Lee! Oh no! What does he want again?
    hd porn

    hd Anal porn
    Holly Hotwife is going about her horny single life: bbw hd porn massaging her wet pussy with a vibrator until she is disturbed by a visitor: her ex-husband, Keiran Lee! Oh no! What does he want again?
    Amateur porn

    BalasHapus
  13. porn videos and download free mobile porn videos. In addition, thousands of videos on our site are all 4k and sex video All you have to do is choose the video you need and enjoy.

    BalasHapus

  14. The oh so very delectable indain HD porn Madison Morgan makes her highly anticipated Brazzers debut and you are in for an absolute treat! Watch Madison showcase her jaw-dropping body and get lost in her eyes as she teases you, and Xander Corvus, pornlove.mobi working up a sensual appetite for sex in a scene that will leave you craving more of this stunning beauty!

    BalasHapus
  15. The oh so very delectable porn tube video Madison Morgan makes her highly anticipated Brazzers debut and you are in for an absolute treat! Watch Madison showcase her


    jaw-dropping body and get lost in her eyes as she teases you, and Xander Corvus, bfxxx working up a sensual appetite for sex in a scene that will leave you craving more of this stunning beauty!


    Jenna Starr is having a steamy affair with her roommate, Kayley Gunner. And Kayley isn't afraid to get caught. rujizz
    But when boyfriend Kyle Mason almost catches them making.

    out in the kitchen, Jenna wants her to hide. She plays nice for jizzwap a minute, but Kyle won't beat it, so Kayley takes down Jenna's shorts and eats her pussy while Jenna tries to play it cool.

    BalasHapus
  16. The oh so very delectable xxx video tube Madison Morgan makes her highly anticipated Brazzers debut and you are in for an absolute treat! Watch Madison showcase her


    jaw-dropping body and get lost in her eyes as she teases you, and Xander Corvus, full xxx video working up a sensual appetite for sex in a scene that will leave you craving more of this stunning beauty!


    Jenna Starr is having a steamy affair with her roommate, Kayley Gunner. And Kayley isn't afraid to get caught. hindi porn videos
    But when boyfriend Kyle Mason almost catches them making.

    out in the kitchen, Jenna wants her to hide. She plays nice for full hot porn a minute, but Kyle won't beat it, so Kayley takes down Jenna's shorts and eats her pussy while Jenna tries to play it cool. deutsche porn

    BalasHapus
  17. Wet latina pussy round ass latina has meaty pussy lips being cameltoe puffy pussy camel toe spy pov test run for hot latina pussy shaved pussy doggystyle my favorite latina housewives latina housewife latina cleaning hungry latina pussy. hot sex porn

    BalasHapus
  18. College Girl Kenzie Reeves really wants to fuck her new boyfriend Van Wylde, but since she promised her dad that she wouldn't lay a finger on him, she's resorting to foot play to please her man. Shocked by Kenzie's lusty behavior, her new conservative step-mom Syren de Mer creates a "chastity blanket" to keep her fiance's daughter and her boyfriend from fucking under their roof. lookmyxxx

    When Kyle Mason returns from folding Alina Ali's laundry, he finds his girlfriend, Aria Kai, making out with and fingering Alina through her enticing onesie butt flap, while they play video games. Kyle is heartbroken until Alina invites him to take her open butt flap for a spin with his hard cock. assistir pornos

    BalasHapus
  19. russia porn free
    The last year with my ex was unbearable. He'd always been jealous, but the further we grew apart, the more suffocating his possessiveness became. If I went out without him I'd have to 'forget' my phone to avoid getting fifty arsey texts But the worst sacrifice I made was losing contact with Tom. Nicki's my oldest friend, but Tom was my closest.

    I met him at my first Saturday job, waitressing at his Dad's restaurant full hot porn

    full xxx porn The night before we went home he dared me to go skinny-dipping. We were sitting on the pier where one of the restaurants had placed a few tables up by the water's edge. I wanted him to look at me, I felt like it was the first time that he'd really seen me. A wave of energy rushed through me, tingling between my thighs.

    free porn watch hindi

    If I hadn't seen the waiter walking over just then, well, I don't know for certain, but I felt sure he'd have kissed me. I pulled my dress on before I was seen and we sat back down to finish our drinks, but the atmosphere had changed completely. Every other night we'd been howling with laughter and taking the piss out of each other. Suddenly we were quiet, the air between us heavy with expectancy. porn hd video

    BalasHapus
  20. Categorías tenemos de sobra, pues hay todo o prácticamente todo: videos porno gay, videos con mujeres maduras, vídeos amateur, sexo anal, incesto, videos xxx gratis y mucho más! Sí solo con decir los nombres de las categorías ya se os pone dura, imaginaros cuando veáis los videos. Seguro que alguna vez has fantaseado con follarte a la vecina o a la madre de un colega de la universidad, pues aquí conseguirás ese tipo de videos que saciarán tu curiosidad sexual y además te excitaran a más no poder. Nuestros videos x son ideales para ver solo o con tu pareja, ya que siempre se pueden sacar nuevas ideas o ponerse un poco a tono por lo que tiene que venir después. Últimos videos porno gratis

    BalasHapus
  21. To be a good secretary, you must always be ready to have sex at rus porno hd at any time of the work day. This beautiful woman seems to be ready and when the boss comes in with a face like he wants to fuck, she kneels down to suck his penis with pleasure. She doesn't even take off her glasses for the fuck.

    incredibly pretty this young woman! Her hair is the color of bright fire, and her passion is flammable. The young guy is very excited, because the girl has a very appetizing pussy. Moreover, when the redhead starts to suck his cock, the redhead does it very nicely. We understand right away that fellatio is her thing. What this couple presents to you in this hdsexteen video, it is a scene of lovers. They make sex in a very hot and passionate way.

    The porn studio that we present to you, has an exclusive theme. Inter-ethnic sex scenes. In this high quality video, you will see a very exciting fuck. The young brunette is on the table, giving a blow job to the guy, who let's say, has a huge cock. The girl has a fleshy mouth, but that doesn't mean she can swallow it all. Still, she makes an effort. Watch out for the scene that follows! The penetration is the highlight of this porn video. When her little hairy pussy gets fucked by the big teube, the young woman moans with pleasure, but also with pain. It's not easy for this brunette, to be fucked by such a big dick. When the fuck happens in cowgirl, the big member in lookmyxxx goes even deeper.

    A bit of sex today, porn in amateur mode with a rather large milf that you can see installed on the bed, where she waits quietly for this young man and his good boner to come and fuck her with all the ardor he can still have at his age! Madam is greedy and he is ready to do anything to make her come, so much to say that it is promising, especially when we see the size of his dick or assistirpornos

    BalasHapus
  22. La jeune Française a vu son ex-copine sur le chemin du retour. Des souvenirs de sexe avec son ex lui sont revenus à l'esprit. Elle n'a pas pu s'en empêcher et a commencé à embrasser son ex sur les lèvres. porno français

    Il est allé chez lui, son ex-copine l'a suivi et est rentré avec lui. Au début, la fille ne voulait pas qu'il vienne, mais elle ne pouvait pas le supporter. Ils ont fait l'amour sauvagement. La fille a éjaculé au moins 4 fois et a eu un très bon orgasme francais . Ils ont passé un bon moment avec leur petit ami.

    BalasHapus
  23. ¿Estás harto de ver siempre los mismos vídeos en los tube? En ultimoporn.com también, por eso hemos creado este portal en donde colgamos vídeos de calidad, únicos, de forma periódica y separada por temáticas, para que puedas encontrar siempre aquellos temas que más te gustan y con la máxima calidad posible. mexican porn

    Aquí encontrarás videos x gratis de todos los tipos y para todos los gustos, sabemos que un día te apetece una cosa y otro día te apetece otra y siempre estarán todos disponibles para ti. Lo importante es que lo disfrutes como nunca! spanish porn

    BalasHapus
  24. best indian porn and more porn videos. All you have to do is check it out and find something that strikes your fancy, you will not be disappointed when you see the huge amount of pron material available on this website.

    BalasHapus